Monday, January 15, 2018
Our 12th to 14th Century Higher Level Scholars in Troyes, France and Worms, Germany
How to understand and interpret and carry out our laws was another thing involving much study. Rabbis in Palestine and rabbis in Babylon worked on such a project, each finally coming up with the Palestinian Talmud and a Babylonian Talmud about sometime between 200 and 400 CE. Talmud means Teaching. They were the records of academic discussions of Jewish Law by generations of well known scholars and jurists in the many academies and in more than one country during those several centuries.
Each one consists of the Mishnah with a gemara, which is both a commentary on and a supplement to the Mishnah. The Mishnah has the core of our Oral Law, compiled by Rabbi Judah Ha-Nasi from previous collections and arranged in a logical order. These dealt mainly with religious laws about agriculture, another dealing with the laws of the Sabbath and festivals. Another topic was Women which dealt with the laws of marriage, divorce and vows people take. Damages was a topic dealing with the treatment of civil and criminal laws. Holy things was another which covered slaughtering animals for food (kosher laws). All this was carefully organized to make it easier to find and deal with.
The Oral Law, handed down by Moses, to each generation orally. It was given by Moses along with his written law. He had been an Egyptian prince and was an educated man, skilled in writing. During the days of the 2nd Temple, the Pharisees and general population upheld this Oral Law. The Sadducees and Essenes didn't and had their own traditions regarding the interpretation of the Written Law. These sects disappeared after the Temple was destroyed in 70 CE and the Oral Law was studied in the many academies, for the people were hungry to learn. Each place had their own way of teaching. Their discussions remained orally only without being written down.
When the Torah is written, it is done by a trained scribe (Sopher) according to careful regulations. If one mistake is made, the whole scroll is discarded, usually buried.
That wasn't enough for these scholars. The Tosaphot came into being. These were important explanations on the Talmud by French and German scholars from the 12 through the 14th centuries. In the beginning, they were supplements to the French Rabbi, Rashi and his Talmud Commentary. These rabbis would frequently criticize and modify Rashi's decisions.
Supposedly, Rashi is my ancestor and that of others as well. He was a French rabbinical scholar who studied in the Rhineland and then returned to Troyes, France where he had a school. While he earned his living from his vineyard, he taught his students and gained a wide reputation for his brilliance. He was famous for his rational commentary on the Tanakh and the Babylonian Talmud. He was known for presenting the direct rational meaning of the text. He brought in the Midrash to his students as well.
![]() |
Lilith and Eve |
These were scholars of higher learning. They dedicated their lives to understanding our laws which were given to benefit us in our lives.
Resource: The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia
Labels: Abraham ibn Ezra, academies, gemara, Mishnah, oral law, Pharisees, Rashi, Sadducees, sopher, Talmud, Tanach, Torah